Fausto sterling how many sexes are there
In my work, I argue that the two-sex system embedded in our society is not adequate to encompass the full spectrum of human sexuality. Some find the changes under way deeply disturbing. Others find them liberating.
While the legal system may have an interest in maintaining only two sexes, our collective biologies do not. My three short articles on the topic listed below are a good place to start, but I provide a list of books for further reading as well.
Anne Fausto-Sterling New ways of thinking about science and human difference. Gender and Early Childhood Development Girls are verbal, while boys are physical— or so the traditional thinking goes. Social Construct I believe that both sex and gender are in part social constructs. Intersex There is a continuity between masculinity and femininity. Pediatrics 3 : e Psychoanalytic Psychology 19 3 Blackless, A.
Charuvastra, A. Derryck, K. Lauzanne, E. Routledge Jordan-Young, R. Cambridge, MA. Fine, C. Delusions of Gender. New York, W.
Norton and Company. Duke University Press Stryker, S. Whittle, Eds. The Transgender Studies Reader. New York, Routledge. But if the state and legal system has an interest in maintaining only two sexes, our collective biological bodies do not. While male and female stand on the extreme ends of a biological continuum, there are many other bodies, bodies such as Suydam's, that evidently mix together anatomical components conventionally attributed to both males and females.
The implications of my argument for a sexual continuum are profound. If nature really offers us more than two sexes, then it follows that our current notions of masculinity and femininity are cultural conceits.
Reconceptualizing the category of "sex" challenges cherished aspects of European and American social organization. Indeed, we have begun to insist on the male-female dichotomy at increasingly early stages, making the two-sex system more deeply a part of how we imagine human life and giving it the appearance of being both inborn and natural. Nowadays, months before the child leaves the comfort of the womb, amniocentesis and ultrasound identify a fetus's sex.
Parents can decorate the baby's room in gender-appropriate style, sports wallpaper—in blue—for the little boy, flowered designs—in pink—for the little girl. Researchers have nearly completed development of technology that can choose the sex of a child at the moment of fertilization. Moreover, modern surgical techniques help maintain the two-sex system. In the past, however, intersexuals or hermaphrodites, as they were called until recently , were culturally acknowledged.
Within 24 hours of the birth of an intersex baby, doctors typically operate to assign the newborn a gender. In I published a modest proposal suggesting that we replace our two-sex system with a five-sex one. In addition to males and females, I argued, we should also accept the categories herms named after "true" hermaphrodites , merms named after male "pseudohermaphrodites" , and ferms named after female "pseudohermaphrodites".
Editor's note: A "true" hermaphrodite bears an ovary and a testis, or a combined gonad called an ovo-testis. A "pseudohermaphrodite" has either an ovary or a testis, along with genitals from the "opposite" sex. I'd intended to be provocative, but I had also been writing tongue in cheek and so was surprised by the extent of the controversy the article unleashed.
Right-wing Christians somehow connected my idea of five sexes to the United Nations-sponsored Fourth World Conference on Women, to be held in Beijing two years later, apparently seeing some sort of global conspiracy at work.
In a new edition of his guide for those who counsel intersexual children and their families, he wrote: "In the 's nurturists They consider all sex differences as artifacts of social construction. In cases of birth defects of the sex organs, they attack all medical and surgical interventions as unjustified meddling designed to force babies into fixed social molds of male and female One writer has gone even to the extreme of proposing that there are five sexes The science fiction writer Melissa Scott wrote a novel entitled Shadow Man , which includes nine types of sexual preference and several genders, including fems people with testes, XY chromosomes, and some aspects of female genitalia , herms people with ovaries and testes , and mems people with XX chromosomes and some aspects of male genitalia.
Others used the idea of five sexes as a starting point for their own multi-gendered theories. Clearly I had struck a nerve. Indeed, a lot has changed since , and I like to think that my article was one important stimulus. Intersexuals have materialized before our very eyes, like beings beamed up onto the Starship Enterprise. They have become political organizers lobbying physicians and politicians to change treatment practices.
More generally, the debate over our cultural conceptions of gender has escalated, and the boundaries separating masculine and feminine seem harder than ever to define.
0コメント